https://www.thelandsite.co.uk/files/articles/e627fba68bb711e99218024b03131eda/iStock-897664288.jpg 309

Illegal Demolition of Victorian Cottages Retrospectively Authorised

Posted by Robinson Allfree on 26th September 2019 -

title

Balancing the desirability of conservation against the need for more new homes is a constant challenge faced by planning professionals. In a guideline High Court case on point, the illegal demolition of three Victorian cottages in an urban area with exceptionally high housing demand was retrospectively authorised.

Construction

The cottages, set in a conservation area, were the last vestiges of a late 19th-century housing development and were surrounded by modern apartment blocks. After they were torn down without planning permission, the local authority issued enforcement notices requiring their complete reconstruction in facsimile.

After the site’s owner appealed, however, a government planning inspector quashed the notices and granted retrospective planning permission for the demolition works. Noting that the cottages were not listed, he described them as remnants of the past in a sea of modern development. They had no major architectural merit and the minimal harm that their demolition had caused to the conservation area was outweighed by the benefit of freeing up the site for housing development.

In challenging that decision, the council argued that it was irrational to describe as beneficial demolition works which had resulted in the loss of historically important buildings and which may well have amounted to a criminal offence. The site had been left vacant and no firm proposals had been put forward for its redevelopment.

However, in dismissing the appeal, the Court noted that the purpose of enforcement notices is remedial, rather than punitive. In those circumstances, any criminality or affront to the rule of law had to be put to one side. Given the site’s prime location in an area of high housing need, the inspector was entitled to conclude that a viable redevelopment proposal would emerge in due course and that it was highly likely that demolition of the cottages would shortly have been authorised in any event.


Robert Ailsby

Kent-based law firm offering commercial property and land development services for investors, developers, landlords and tenants. We deal with business sales and purchases, land development, business leases, landlord & tenant matters and commercial lending.

Link to Robinson Allfree business profile

16th December 2021
Flexible Working – Here To Stay?
Flexible working has become the norm, rather than the exception, for many of us since March 2020.
Read more
2nd November 2021
UK Autumn Budget 2021 - The Fight Against Economic Crime
Chancellor Rishi Sunak delivered his Autumn Budget and Spending Review on 27 October, which he stated that "today’s Budget does begin the work of preparing for a new economy post Covid."
Read more
27th September 2021
COVID-19 and Hybrid Working
Our key priority will always be the safety of our colleagues, clients and visitors as we continue to minimise the risks of COVID-19.
Read more