https://www.thelandsite.co.uk/files/articles/e627fba68bb711e99218024b03131eda/iStock-1042860338.jpg 306

High Court Boosts Plans for New Neighbourhood of 1,200 Homes

Posted by Robinson Allfree on 11th November 2019 -

title

The mere fact that a development proposal may encounter difficulties and eventually prove undeliverable does not generally justify a refusal of planning permission. The High Court made that point in breathing new life into plans to construct a whole new neighbourhood of 1,200 homes.

Housing construction

In promoting the project, the would-be developer emphasised a shortfall in housing land in the area and that 30 percent of the new homes would be affordable. The local authority, however, refused consent, citing traffic congestion and air quality concerns. After a public inquiry, the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government followed the advice of one of his planning inspectors and confirmed the refusal of planning permission.

In upholding the developer’s challenge to that decision, however, the Court found that a crucial part of the Secretary of State’s decision was something of a muddle. He had irrationally focused on concerns that the project would be undeliverable because the developer did not own playing fields through which a key access to up to 700 homes was proposed to run.

The Court noted that, as a general rule, the question of whether a proposal can be implemented is irrelevant to the decision whether to grant permission. There is no legal requirement that consent must be refused unless a developer commits itself to implementing a proposal. Doubts about the scheme’s deliverability were thus not a material consideration which should have weighed in the balance.

The Court rejected the developer’s argument that, by engaging in unrecorded and informal conversations with objectors to the proposal during the inquiry and a site visit, the inspector had given an appearance of bias. The refusal of planning permission was nevertheless quashed and the Secretary of State was directed to consider the matter afresh in the light of the Court’s ruling.


Robert Ailsby

Kent-based law firm offering commercial property and land development services for investors, developers, landlords and tenants. We deal with business sales and purchases, land development, business leases, landlord & tenant matters and commercial lending.

Link to Robinson Allfree business profile

16th December 2021
Flexible Working – Here To Stay?
Flexible working has become the norm, rather than the exception, for many of us since March 2020.
Read more
2nd November 2021
UK Autumn Budget 2021 - The Fight Against Economic Crime
Chancellor Rishi Sunak delivered his Autumn Budget and Spending Review on 27 October, which he stated that "today’s Budget does begin the work of preparing for a new economy post Covid."
Read more
27th September 2021
COVID-19 and Hybrid Working
Our key priority will always be the safety of our colleagues, clients and visitors as we continue to minimise the risks of COVID-19.
Read more